Went down a wormhole trying to organize early non-album tracks into something like chronological groups. Did research as possible and then put on headphones and used my ears to try to parse the home recordings via tech, recording quality, and to some extent songwriting. (Has all this already been sorted?)
BILL NELSON: A Thought Experiment About Imaginary Releases of Stray Tracks, 1979-1982
What if Bill Nelson had been able to release his new music at the speed of creation, rather than being in a situation where the recordings trickled out in a way that obscured their approximate chronology? It seems impossible to accurately reconstruct that chronology, but song credits and the sonic evidence get you pretty close.
Red Noise 12-inch
Instantly Yours
Wonder Toys that Last Forever
Ideal Homes
Acquitted by Mirrors
Quit Dreaming-Adjacent Single #1(Leckie/Mobile Unit = album outtakes)
White Sound
Mr. Magnetism Himself
Atom Man Loves Radium Girl
Quit Dreaming-Adjacent Single #2 (Presumably pure home recordings, but robust!)
The World and His Wife
Dancing Music
Dream Car Romantics
Home Recordings Part 1 (35 minutes)
These feature Nelson’s original “rhythm unit” - the most technologically naive recordings. All surely tracks he had ready at the time of recording “Quit Dreaming.”
Touch & Glow
Turn to Fiction
Hers is a Lush Situation
Dada Guitare
Rooms with Brittle Views
Shadowland
Be My Dynamo
All My Wives Were Iron
The Beat that Can’t Go Wrong Today
Sleepcycle
King of the Cowboys
Home Recordings Part 2 (43 minutes)
New tech appears in the home recordings, and the recording sonics improve. Some tunes lean earlier, while many usher in sounds and songwriting impulses of “The Love That Whirls” period and possibly a bit later (c. “Chimera”). Side one is a strong pop music gambit.
Side One: Vocal Tracks (22 minutes)
Dancing in the Wind
When the Birds Return
Love Without Fear
Indiscretion
Love in the Abstract
Side Two: Instrumental Tracks (21 minutes)
Birds of Tin
Junc Sculpture
Daily Bells
Carnival
Rhythm Unit
Konnie Buys a Kodak
Tony Goes to Tokyo
Spring
Love That Whirls-Adjacent Studio Tracks (30 minutes)
A more generous version of the “Flaming Desire and Other Passions” mini-LP. “Hard Facts” is apparently a home recording and sounds so good that it might be latest track in this list.
Eros Arriving (single version)
Haunting in My Head
Flesh
He and Sleep Were Brothers
The Passion
The Burning Question
Hard Facts from the Fiction Department
What Happens Next?
“Dancing on a Knife’s Edge” is the only dangling track before the BN stray tracks obviously move on to new pastures. I’d say it’s a “Chimera” or “Holy Ghost” adjacent track.
My old cassette tape …’drop outs’, ‘wow and flutter’ and all….
Radio Session…March 1981
Bill and Ian in the studios of Piccadilly Radio (Manchester)
Host back then before his BBC move…. Fellow northerner…Mark Radcliffe….
Bill and Ian improv over Bill’s Revox B77 ….Energy-Bow &Sax respectively….
Hope it’s this session on the upcoming box set !
Stunning !
I've attempted a more objective/evidenced chronology...
Sorting Solo Bill Nelson 1979-1985
This is an esoteric document, neither a sessionography nor a discography - but rather a mixture of the two.
The goal is to establish a chronology for all the known songs of this period - which is impossible, because recording dates aren’t known for many of them, and release dates may or may not reflect the recentness of the compositions/recordings.
So, I have logged songs by the earliest date that I can determine they existed - recording session dates, when that information is available, and initial release date, when that’s all we know for sure. (Kid Jensen sessions are ambiguous, since they used home recordings. If any of them were live sessions, I can’t find that information.)
At the very least, this is an objective baseline for pondering further refinement of chronology, using our ears.
Please alert me to errors and omissions.
1978 (and early 1979)
Final Red Noise recordings, plus earlier b-sides. Included here because two tracks first appeared on solo BN singles:
Instantly Yours
Wonder Toys that Last Forever
Ideal Homes
Acquitted by Mirrors
(Disposable, included on Quit Dreaming)
1979 February-June
Quit Dreaming recorded with John Leckie and the Mobile Unit. I suspect that February is covering Disposable, which was played by Red Noise, still active at that time.
Album tracks
White Sound
Mr. Magnetism Himself
Atom Man Loves Radium Girl
1980 November
From Brussels with Love compilation released:
The Shadow Garden (would later appear on Ritual Echo)
1981 February
Single released:
Rooms with Brittle Views
Dada Guitare
1981 February or March
John Peel broadcast (home recordings):
Konnie Buys A Kodak
The Art Of Vision
Boom Year Ahead
Afterlife
1981 March-August
Home recordings used as b-sides on Quit Dreaming singles:
Be My Dynamo
All My Wives Were Iron
Birds of Tin
Love in the Abstract
Turn to Fiction
Hers is a Lush Situation
1981 May
Quit Dreaming released
Sounding the Ritual Echo released
1981 May
The Nottingham live tape includes Sleepcycle and several tracks with unknown titles.
1981 June
Kid Jensen broadcast:
Rooms With Brittle Views
Stay Young
Sleep Cycle
Jazz (Richard Jobson vocals)
1981 “between spring and winter”
The Love That Whirls Sessions:
Album tracks
Eros Arriving (single version)
Haunting in My Head
Flesh
He and Sleep Were Brothers
The Passion
The Burning Question
Five tracks that would eventually appear on “Savage Gestures for Charms Sake (released December 1983).
1981 November
Tony Goes to Tokyo released
Das Kabinett released (commissioned in early 1981)
1982 April
ABM 1 released:
Konny Buys a Kodak
When the Birds Return
The Beat that Can’t Go Wrong Today
1982 June
The Love That Whirls released (see session, above, for related b-sides)
La Belle et la Bete released (recorded in early 1982)
1982 July
Kid Jensen broadcast:
A Dip In The Swimming Pool Reactor
M1 (Still Under Construction)
Zen
1982 Autumn
Chimera recorded
1982 October
ABM 2 released:
King of the Cowboys
Shadowland
Carnival
Spring
1982 November
Single release (previously unreleased home recordings included on the Permanent Flame 7-inch box, issued separately in 1983):
Touch & Glow
Dancing in the Wind
Love without Fear
1983 January
Kid Jensen broadcast of four tracks, three of which would appear on ABM 3, released May 1983:
Dancing on a Knife’s Edge
Indiscretion
Contemplation
Time Tracking
1983 February-March
The Invisibility Exhibition live performances, featuring many tracks that would appear on Chamber of Dreams (released in early 1985), a few untitled numbers, and an instrumental version of Indiscretion.
1983 May
Chimera released
1983 November
ABM 4 released:
World and His Wife
Dream Car Romantics
Dancing Music
1983 December
Savage Gestures for Charm’s Sake released. Five songs taken from TLTW sessions, one from earlier.
1984 May
ABM 5 released:
Hard Facts from the Fiction Department
Daily Bells
Rhythm Unit
Junc Sculpture
1984 December
ABM 6 released (“Giants of the Perpetual Wurlitzer”).
The Strangest Things, The Strangest Times
Phantom Gardens*
French Promenade
Golden Mile
West Deep*
Threnodia*
* Later re-released on Chance Encounters.
1985 January
Trial by Intimacy released
1985 February
Two-Fold Aspect of Everything Released
1985 June
Sex, Psyche, Etc. 12-inch released (Orchestra Arcana)
All extremely fascinating, and one of my absolute favorite periods of Bill’s career. Full disclosure: the Kid and I go way back and have been Nelson blood brothers since the late 90s. And so I’ve been in this wormhole with him, via a lively email exchange. Today, while on a long train ride, I tracked the release dates of the various singles and “Acquitted by Mirrors” freebies via the Dreamsville discography and was surprised to see how late “The World and His Wife,” “Indiscretion” and “Dream Car Romantics” are in his discography: and yet Nelson himself apparently greenlit “The World and His Wife” and “Indiscreation” to replace the “Vistamix” tracks on “Quit Dreaming.” So I think TKK is right to think the recording dates aren’t as aligned with the release date as we might think.
Is there any glimmer of a hint that “Quit Dreaming” and “The Love That Whirls” are due for the Cherry Red box-set treatment? I don’t think my 58 year old heart could withstand the wonder of “The Love That Whirls” in 5.1 but I’m willing to risk it.
A Quit Dreaming box set should be able to sort all this out, here's hoping! ,🤞😀
Yes, this is great work, TKK. Thank you for it.
Agreeing with Ed's comment and expanding on it, to integrate all the various radio sessions into your list (see separate thread about the sessions) would be useful because the sessions all come with recording or broadcast dates and show what Bill's current ongoing work was at the time he paused to do a session for radio.
With the exception, I think, of Contemplation, Bill rarely returned to a song long after first recording it - he's always moving onwards! - so radio session dates are probably within days or weeks of any first home recording dates.
We're close to having a 1979-1984 (85?) timeline for known songs of that period. And what an exciting, experimental time that was! Dropping into that timeline such items as dates of UK and US tours would be a bonus as well.
Thanks again for getting this far.
A comprehensive breakdown. I’ve wondered and speculated about these. Perhaps you could create similar for Noise Candy.
Wow, that's quite a wormhole you've been down, but worth the effort. How long did this take?
Would it possibly be appropriate to bracket Indiscretion, Dancing on a Knife's Edge, Contemplation, and Time Tracking apart, because they were recorded at the same time for a Kid Jensen session on BBC Radio 1? I think they were post Love That Whirls and pre Chimera (and what a brilliant session that was - those recordings still sound as fresh as when they were first broadcast).
PS Great work TKK!